An updated version of my book about reading and education will appear in a few months. It focuses on developments in reading education since it was published, including the emergence of the “science of reading” approach to instruction.  This post is based on material that will appear in the new edition.

In light of the Dec 2024 article in the Atlantic about Lucy Calkins, I am reposting this piece of mine from a few years ago.

AI tools that do remarkable things are appearing so often it’s impossible to keep up. I have just tried the innocuously named NotebookLM from Google and think you’ll be interested in the results.

I see that there are >100 responses to my last post, which will take me a little time to go through. The exchange is also continuing on the SPELLtalk list. I won't have time to copy all of that over to this site, I'm afraid. 

I don’t know if we agree about phonics, but let’s get back to phonemic awareness. Thanks for clarifying that you don’t advocate teaching 44 phonemes as a prerequisite skill. I had in mind the many people who are doing this.

You’re obviously committed to reading education and to achieving consensus about what works and why. Engaging in thoughtful, civil discussions about challenging issues is essential, of course, and I am responding with that in mind. Although I’m responding to your post, I’m addressing views that are shared by many people, which you’ve helpfully summarized. 

Teaching reading to African American children: When home and school language differ, an article Mark coauthored with Dr. Julie Washington, is now out in the summer issue of American Educator. The article includes a discussion of African American English and its influence on reading, as well as recommendations for teaching

Let’s talk about ”background knowledge.” The term refers to things a child knows about the world–about people, events, and situations; categories such as animals and clothing; topics such as animal habitats and how plants grow. These are things we use language to talk and write about. This knowledge provides the “background” or context for understanding a text.Unsurprisingly, there are differing views about the role of background knowledge in early reading.